|
I
can't say it any better than Mr. Wolf, so I'm not going to waste
your time or mine even trying. ( For more from David visit http://www.agelessmarketing.com.
) What I will try to ponder on is not how did it come to this or
why. David does an excellent job of that in his book "Ageless
Marketing."
What I'm trying to figure out is what comes next. Now that advertising
is loosing its viability, what if anything stands in the wings of
commerce, ready to take its place?
Let's
check certain things off the list right now. Direct Marketing. The
audience has ADD. Nobody reads anymore. On-line Advertising. Tell
me the last five banners you recall seeing. I rest my case. Branded
Entertainment. Can you say voodoo ROI boys and girls? Buzz Marketing.
"Will you take our picture? How do you like this cool camera?
Well fuck you too, Charlie." Viral Marketing. "No, no.
It worked for HotMail. It'll work for you. Give it time. And a little
more cash. Trust me." Advergaming. No, no. this really is cool.
It really is. No, it's not as cool as Grand Theft Auto. But it's
got your name on it." Word Of Mouth. Well, no. We can't project
how many people will actually tell their friends. But we can..."
Wow, I'm running out of alternatives.
Let's
see. Product Placement in Rap Music. " Yo bitch. I'm rich.
My Navigator makes whack niggas twitch." Drive Time Radio "
We'll be back in five with another Power 107 Mix but first here's..."
Out Of Home. "Don't you make me have to come back there little
mister."
What's
that leave us with? Search Engine Advertising. That will be $7,000
for the AdWord "Automobile" E-Bay. "According to
the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), approximately one in every 50
consumers has been a victim of identity theft."
Oh
shit. I'm out of places to place my advertising. I got $500 million
to spend. What do I spend it on? Hmmmmmm. What happens if I just
put it over here? In the cash on hand column. Or maybe over here?
In the price support box.
Ouoooo!
That looks great in my YTD numbers when I compare it to last year.
Plus I get to say I cut my cost of sales by 50%. What happens if
sales actually go up? I'm lovin' the sound of this.
But
wait. I just bought that new house in Darian. If I pull the advertising
budget, why do they need a CMO? I got it! I got it! I'll pull 75%
of the budget and put the rest of it in price support and one big
honkin' Super Bowl Spot. Now you're talkin' pure genius moves. I
rock!
You
laugh. It might just work. Consider the point of diminishing returns.
What makes more sense? Spending $350 million on advertising nobody
will pay attention to? Or taking $350 million direct to your bottom
line? What would you do if you were Mercedes-Benz with only $28
million in domestic sales last year? Or General Motors faced with
laying off 25% of its work force which also happens to be 9% of
its customers?
I
feel a new Battle Cry coming on. "Zero Ad Waste. Zero Advertising."
Too radical?
Then
try this on for size. "$500 Million To Make America Better.
Zero On Advertising."
If
John Hayes, the chief marketing officer at American Express took
that idea to Bob Wright, CEO, NBC Universal and said, We won't be
spending a dime on advertising next year, but we will be spending
six million bucks a week on making life better for millions and
millions of Americans. We'll put up 50% of the production costs.
You convince Marty Sheen to help us do it every Sunday night. He's
outta work. It'll be the ultimate wish fulfillment/reality show.
What do you think, Bob? Top rated show on Television?
Let's
make it better. What if John Hayes challenged other CMOs to do the
same thing. Not with their entire ad budget. Just a million bucks
a week. Not on NBC, but on CBS. Would anybody step up? What if we
called it "Step Up America?" Would people watch corporate
America doing something to improve the quality of their lives instead
of adding to the clutter of their lives? Would CBS even be interested?
Send
me an e-mail about what you think. harry@harrywebber.com.
Stay
tuned.
|