The Transformational Idea, Is The Idea.

I hope the Summer is allowing you to keep cool. Me? I was born cool. But that is another story.

Subscriptions are still coming in. Thank you Advertising Age for sending those folks interested in the Post-Advertising Era to our side of town. We are still not up to quota on our subscriptions yet. Keep those emails coming. If you want to pay $126 bucks a year to get the new improved MadisonAveNew each week, along with four of your most pressing questions answered the best way I can during the course of the year click here.

Meanwhile, this weeks question was submitted by subscriber Dennis T. of Seattle, WA.

This Weeks Question:What will replace advertising in the Post-Advertising Era?

The easy answer is "Post-Advertising." But we never-ever do anything easy. The accurate answer is "Transformational Ideas will replace Advertising in the Post-Advertising   Era."   This will call for a wholesale reshuffle of all of the uncommon wisdom we currently try to shove down our client's throats as "thought leadership."

Transformational Ideas take a great deal of heavy lifting to define, let alone execute. The obvious first step lies in the definition of what exists now that is in need of transformation. Gaining an accurate description of your current status in the marketplace and a clear demarcation of the playing field is not as easy as it seems.

The first place to start is a clear understanding that what you know of your current audience may not necessarily jive with what your current audience knows about you.

It's a lot like the shock that Cognac distributors had at discovering that huge segments of their audience were upscale, black and single. Conventional wisdom had put the market at suburban, white and occasional. When Hennessy did their homework, it lead them to a Transformational Idea. Position their brand to Blacks who happened to be Early Adaptors. They didn't just run ther ads in Essence and Black Enterprise. They chose to run themin Wired and Fast Company with ads that were obviously directed to Black tech-buffs.

The Post Advertising Era will demand that transformational thinking go significantly beyond the media plan and the creative brief. So in defining the playing field we have to factor in more than just demographic, psychographic and geographic profiles of the audience.

We need to consider probability scenarios for economic trends, business continuity issues for key industry sectors, and societal trends that may change entire game plans the way mp3 and html did in their respective decades.

That complex roadmap will provide us with a dynamic overview of the worldview of our current audience. If we were serious about it, we would model all of the variables in a complex adaptive system model on our local mainframe. Then we would be able to begin to work on the perimeters of our Transformational Idea overlay. Why? Because now we have a fairly accurate idea of what can and cannot be transformed.

Whereas advertising is all about words, pictures and strategic framework, what will come to replace advertising will be all about content, context and probable outcomes. What do we want the audience to know? How do we want the audience to react once they know? Where do we think the knowledge will drive the audience from where they are now? How will that audience action bring about transformational change in the status quo?

Where do we start when we strive to come up with a transformational idea? We start with the outcome. Whereas traditional advertising is only concerned with the creation of awareness among the audience, the transformational idea is concerned with the perception of value among the audience. In other words, how do you transform the value perception of the audience from "So what?" to "Gotta have it?"

The answer to that question is not simple to explain or to conceive. But from time to time we will let our subscribers in on our progress in evolving exactly what the solution will entail.

Stay strong.

 

 

 

 



WEDNESDAY
July 23, 2008
ISSUE 205

ABOUT ME

ARCHIVE

CONTACT ME

AGENDA

MOST READ

MAD002
The Journey
to Great

MAD009
The Death of
Advertising

MAD023
The Boy Who
Broke My Heart

MAD025
Too Busy for
Temptation

MAD072
The Rise and
Fall of the
Creative Class

MAD006
The Battle for
Coca-Cola
Rages On

MAD059
Happy Birthday
to Me

MAD060
The City that
Spawned the
Age of
Advertising

MAD066
The True Cool

MAD095
The Creeping
Influence Of All
Things Emo.

MAD015
The Four Great
Myths of Global
Branding

MAD026
The One True
Thing

MAD030
The Lost Art of
Persuasion

MAD021
Dare To Be
Great: The Mad
Genius of The
"Matrix"

MAD071
Boomers
Downshift
To Neutral

MAD092
Advertising
Immunity. Can
It Be Cured In
Our Lifetime?

MAD100
Breathing New
Life Into
American
Business

LINKS WE LIKE

HarryWebber.com

BrandedFilm.com

TheGaspCompany.com

Addcoachinggroup.com

BrAnswers.com

POWER BLOGS

Hollwood-Elsewhere

AdRants

Adland

Ads Of The World

Ad Goodness

Beyond Madison Av

Jaffe Juice

Make The Logo
Bigger

Random Culture

Entrepreneur Success Blog

American Copywriter

Digital Axle

Adgabber.com

RECENT
ARCHIVES

MAD 204
The Client Is The Audience.


MAD 203
Brand New Brands.


MAD 202
What's The Plan, Stan? .

MAD 201
Less Is Now More.


MAD 200
The Dinner That Changed Everything.


MAD 199
The Things That
Matter.


MAD 198
The Other Harry Webber


MAD 197
And The Band
Played
On

MAD 196
NeoAdvertising 7

MAD 195
NeoAdvertising 6


MAD 194
NeoAdvertising 5


MAD 193
NeoAdvertising 4


MAD 192
NeoAdvertising 3


MAD 191
NeoAdvertising 2


MAD 190
NeoAdvertising 1


MAD 189
The Purpose of Creativity


MAD 188
A Moment of Silence


MAD 187
Back To Basics .

MAD 186
The Right Man's Burden.


MAD 185
The End of Advertising As Usual.


MAD 184
The Beauty That Never Fades.


MAD 183
Be Careful To Always Think Twice.


MAD 182
"Yes. And No."


MAD 181
Big, Friggin'. Scary Idea
.

MAD 180
Building A Company
Cult-ure .


MAD 179
Doing Whatever It Takes.

MAD 178
The Art Of Our Science

MAD 177
NeoInflation Creation

MAD 176
Can Lean Advertising
Become Lean-Forward
Advertising?


MAD 175
The Lean Advertising
Network: Learning
What We Already Know


MAD 174

Relentless
Creativity.


MAD 173
Constant Change
For The Better.


MAD 172
Lean On This.

MAD 171
Take The Red Pill


MAD 170
And Now, Lean
Advertising


MAD 169
The Lost Art Of
Art Direction


MAD 168
Reality Check

MAD 167
Making Your Own
Dreams Come
True

MAD 166
Gracias Por Todo

MAD 165
Buzz Off

MAD 164
The Future of Branding


MAD 163
Me, Unmasked


MAD 162
Nobody Knows
Nothin'


MAD 161
Behind the
8 Ball. Ahead
Of The Curve.

MAD 160
What Do We
Think We're
Doing?

MAD 159
Engagement
Ring

MAD 158
Ma(Duh!)son
Avenue


MAD 157
Funnel
Cloud
Heading
Our Way

MAD 156
Adaptive
Branding
Hit The
Road

MAD 155
How To Sing
The Blues


MAD 154

How to Pitch
In 2007

MAD153
Joost:
Television
Perfected

MAD152
What If gods
Were One
Of Us?


MAD151
Are We Smart
Enough?

MAD150
The Ultimate
Lie.

MAD149
The Art Of
Self Defense.

MAD148
In Praise
(And Dread)
Of Creative
Collaboration

MAD147
Adaptive
Branding And
The Millennials.

MAD146
Heard Any
Good Brand
Stories
Lately?

MAD145
Terms Of
Engagement.

MAD144
The Next
Generation
Of Trouble
Makers.

MAD143
What Are
You Hiding
From?

MAD142
Help Wanted:
No Excellence
Neccesary.

MAD141
The New
Creativity:
Building
Brands That
Matter.

MAD140
The Client's
God-Given
Right To Say
Drop Dead.

MAD139
Ladies And
Gentlemen
I Give You
The Audience.

MAD138
Change Or
Die: The
Adaptive
Brand Lives.


MAD137
Clients Kick
IT UP A Notch.


MAD136
Money For
Nothing And
The Kicks
For Free.


MAD135
Too Cool To
Care.


MAD134
Pimp My
Life.


MAD133
Why Don't You
Get Youself
A Real Job.


MAD132
What Would
You Do If
You Had To
Start Over
From Scratch?


MAD131
The Dance Heard
Round The World.


MAD130
Why Brand
Character
Matters Now
More Than
Ever.

 

 


WHO READS
MADISON AVENEW

ADVERTISING/PR AGENCIES
A.C. Nielsen Co
Anomoly
Arnold Worldwide
BBDO NY
Bravo Group
Brodeur Porter
Novelli
Brandimensions
Burston Marsteller
Campbell Ewald
Carat USA
Cimarron Group
Cramer Krasselt
Crispin Porter &
Bogusky
BP Media Relations

MORE

ENTERTAINMENT

19 Entertainment
20th Century Fox
Agency for MPerforming Arts
Ask Jeeves, Inc.
Barnes & Noble
CAA
CBS Studio Center
CBS, Inc.
CineWorks
Clear Channel
Courtroom TV Network
DIC Entertainment
DirecTV
Disney Worldwide Services
Electric Lightwave
Emeril’s Homebase Exxon Mobile Corp.
ESPN
Fandango
Franklin Weinrib Rudell
Golf TV
GE/NBC
Harpo Productions

MORE

TECHNOLOGY

Accelovation
AG Technologies
Allied Signal, Inc.
Altavista Company
Apple Computer
Adobe Systems
AT&T Corp.
Bell Laboratories
Boeing
Cisco Systems
Coca-Cola
Computer
Sciences Corp.
Compass
Communications
Computerwise,
Inc.
Cornerstone
Research
Cybernostic Group
Cyveillance, Inc.
Danger.com
Dell Computer
Corp.
Diebold
Digitas
Energy Group
Networks
E. D. S.
Edaptivity.com
Electronic Arts
Equinix, Inc.
Evocative, Inc
GHI Technologies
GTech, Corp.
Genentech, Inc
General Electric
Plastics
GoDaddy Software
Hewlett-Packard
Hollywood
Interactive
Honeywell, Inc.
Hughes Network
IBM Corporation
Knology Holdings
Intel Corporation
Layered
Technologies
Macromedia, Inc.

MORE

CONSUMER PRODUCTS

Abbott Laboratories
Affiliated Foods
Air Canada
Allegiance
American Airlines, Inc.
Healthcare
Amazon.com
Allied Signal, Inc.
Amaco Corporation
Anheuser Busch
Apple Computer
Berretta, USA
Bausch & Lomb
Bayer Corp.
Borders, Inc.
Calvin Klein Cosmetics
Canadian Mental
Christian & Timbers
Company
Colgate Palmolive
Conrail
Cooper Oil Tool Div.
Corp. Edison Group
Delta Air Lines
Dr Pepper/Seven Up
Eli Lilly & Company
Estee Lauder
Ethan Allen
Federal Express Corp.
First Health Growth
Health Assn
H.J. Heinz Co.
Heinz Service Company
Hilton Hospitality
Hotjobs.com
The Home Depot
HQ Global Workplaces
Humana
Ikea NA Services
International Paper
Johanna Foods Inc.
Johns Hopkins
Johns Manville
Johnson & Johnson
Joseph E. Seagram
Kaiser Permianente
Kinkos, Inc
Masonic Homes
Mead Corp.
Merck & Co.
McDonald's
McKesson
National Gypsum
Norfolk&Southern Railway
Nike
Office Max
Oliver Peoples
Pepsi-Cola
Pfizer
Phillip Morris

MORE

PUBLICATIONS

Adrants
Adweek
American Busines
Media
American City
Business Journal
Bloomberg Financial
Brandweek
C|Net
Chicago Tribune
CMP Publications,
Corbis Corp.
Cox Newspapers
Crain
Communications
Dow Jones
DowJones-
Telerate
Forbes, Inc.
Getty Images
Hachette Filipacchi
Harper Collins
Houghton Miffin Co.
Knight-Ridder

MORE

FINANCIAL FIRMS

Assurant, Inc.
American Express
American Family
Insurance
Automatic Data
Bank Of America
Bank One
Banque Paribus
Bear Sterns MSecurity
Booze Allen Hamilton
Central Life Insurance
Charles Schwab & Co.
Citicorp Global
Information Network
Chase Manhatten
Bank
Commonwealth
Dean Witter
Debartolo Properties
Deutsche Bank
Dorland Sweeny
Jones
Discover Financial
Services
Ernst & Young
Fannie Mae
Farmers Insurance
First American Title
Guardian Life
Insurance

MORE

GOVERNMENT/
NGO

42nd Communications
Squadron, Maxwell
AFB
Admin Office of U.S.
Courts
Air Force Logistics
Command.
American Heart Assn.
Autism Partnership
The Art Institute
International
American Red Cross
Cal Dept. of Social
Services
Canadian Wheat Board
City Of Philadelphia
City of Los Angeles
City of New York
Commonwealth of
Kentucky
Communicom Services,
Alabama
Development Prog.
DOD Network
Eastern Band of
Cherokee Indians
Federal Reserve
Board
Hadassah Corporation
Harvard University
Institute For
Advanced Study
Internal Revenue
Service
John D & Cathrine T. McArthur Foundation
The United Nations

MORE